Standardized Corruption

Here’s the right-wing plan for our schools: First,  cut off as much money as possible so that schools have to fight for every penny of funding. Second, destroy the teachers unions to destroy tenure and seniority.  Teachers will then have to fight to keep their jobs from the first day they are hired until their last day of work. Third, judge the resulting competition almost solely on a single measure: the standardized test.  Fourth,  wherever possible, dismantle public schools when you can and sell them off to private interests.

Last, exaggerate  and publicize the failures of the public schools while obscuring the failures and exaggerating the successes of the charter schools. This is not a conspiracy. This is simply the practical results of a “market-based” approach to public education rooted in a system of so-called “accountability.”  It’s hyper-competition. Markets are a-moral; ethics matter only if ethics can be used to increase profits. Markets are also never free; they are shaped by the participants in that market to maximize profitability. Right and wrong is secondary.

If the participants in a market are allowed to fully maximize their potentials for profit, that is, to fully deregulate the market, corruption is inevitable. The financial markets were radically deregulated– on the behest of Wall Street– and it led to the rescission and to ongoing fiscal crises all over the world. That’s what is happening more and more in the increasingly “market driven” public education system (see here and here).  If the corruption of financial capital caused catastrophic problems, imagine the results of this corruption of human capital.

The Competition is Coming

Those of us in proprietary online education have lived a charmed life, I think. The first wave of public online programs, which began nearly a decade ago, more or less failed. The public schools, too, seem to have dropped their historical role of making a low-cost, or at least a reasonably priced, education widely available to almost everyone. Thanks to the Republican far right’s success at choking off federal funds, costs continue to be shifted to individuals through tuition hikes.

That political process created a huge demographic gap which the for-profits (admittedly, also thanks to a great degree to regulators sleeping on the job) successfully rushed to fill. There’s no real low-cost alliterative at this point. Eventually, I think, the public sector is going to fill their historic role again, although it may be the community colleges, rather than the universities, that will eventually offer the low-cost online education necessary to any democracy.

I’ve described this before as a tortoise and hare race. The proprietary schools are fast but in the long run they can’t beat public education. Once this first, “it’s new so it must be better” phase has passed, proprietary education, like the charter schools, will find a niche, but won’t take over the system. The recent decision of several business schools to create online MBA programs isn’t quite the low-cost alternative, but it’s a sign that the tortoise is out there, slow but sure.

Stupidity as Public Policy

I knew the deficit debate was coming, but the sheer brutal stupidity of it is shocking. Still, if you do a search on “the deficit isn’t really a problem” you get thousands of hits on arguments that do make sense; here, here, and here . So there’s no shortage of people saying that the emperor has no clothes. What perpetuates stupidity? Or, rather, who has a vested interest in perpetuating stupidity?

One explanation is that the Republican Party, along with some very powerful and rich right-wing ideologues, are so well attuned to the media’s 24 hour hype-for-profit desperation that they can create a rhetorical mountain out of any molehill they might choose. The mainstream Democrats seem paralyzed by either political cowardice or a misguided pragmatism. Stupidity is the real third rail of U.S. politics.

Too much of it is too transparently intentional to be simple ignorance. Some people, apparently, really do believe that up is down, and that the moon is made of green cheese. At least part of the nonsense sector is simply cynical or cowardly, of course, but I think much of it is simple stupidity. This current wave of anti-intellectualism has lasted more than a generation. We’ve been dumbed down.

Stupidity reproduces itself wherever creationism is equated with evolutionary theory, or climate change reduced to an opinion, or Christians, contend that gay marriage will destroy marriage. We all make stupid decisions;the stupid sector, though, contends that knowledge and self-reflection, those processes that can counter stupidity, are either unnecessary or dangerous. Stupid is as stupid does.